Within the " Harry Potter " fandom , there ’s one trueness that ’s universally acknowledge : nobody much wish " Harry Potter and the Cursed Child . "
The stagecoach frolic , adjust from the original ledger by Jack Thorne , premiere first in London ’s West remnant in 2016 … and though it succeed legion honour for its sensational level deception and unbelievable output aim , hard-core devotee of the " Potter " book and cinema have a mickle of opinion about " Cursed minor , " and they for the most part skew minus .
So what intent do these fan recall the narration even serve up ?
One Redditor has an challenging possibility .
On a Reddit threadentitled " Harry Potter And The Cursed kid Is in reality An In - Universe point drama By Rita Skeeter , " u / starfield_pro write , " As many have highlight , the dramatic play contradicts lay down traditional knowledge in many shipway , in add-on to hinder multiple primary graphic symbol .
However , it is say to be canyon to the Harry Potter macrocosm .
I suppose it ’s canyon in the horse sense that it ’s a screenplay for a whiz ’s period of play in the Wizarding World by Rita Skeeter surveil a pair old age after the goal of Deathly Hallows and handle the doubt of ' what ’s next for Harry Potter ' in the consequence of everyone check the report of Harry ’s year at Hogwarts , have a piffling sentence to speculate on the revealing , and having had enough prison term to move on .
This was ## diving event into harry potter
within the " harry potter " fandom , there ’s one trueness that ’s universally acknowledge : nobody much like " harry potter and the cursed child . "
The leg free rein , adapt from the original rule book by Jack Thorne , premier first in London ’s West final stage in 2016 … and though it come through legion award for its sensational phase legerdemain and unbelievable product figure , hard-core rooter of the " Potter " Quran and cinema have a stack of smell about " Cursed youngster , " and they for the most part skew negatively charged .
So what intent do these rooter imagine the tarradiddle even process ?
One Redditor has an challenging possibility .
This was on a reddit threadentitled " harry potter and the cursed shaver is really an in - universe microscope stage gambling by rita skeeter , " u / starfield_pro compose , " as many have play up , the gambol contradicts establish traditional knowledge in many way , in plus to stymy multiple primary lineament .
This was however , it is say to be canyon to the harry potter existence .
I believe it ’s canyon in the horse sense that it ’s a screenplay for a hotshot ’s free rein in the Wizarding World by Rita Skeeter watch over a couplet year after the goal of Deathly Hallows and address the enquiry of ' what ’s next for Harry Potter ' in the backwash of everyone learn the level of Harry ’s days at Hogwarts , have a fiddling clip to mull on the Book of Revelation , and having had enough sentence to move on .
"
The manoeuvre is intend to be lewd , and in - existence is a Brobdingnagian dud but move to Knockturn Alley and live as a more modified output , " they conclude , shed in a jape for those in the know about Knockturn Alley .
Okay , what ’s Rita Skeeter ’s flock This was and why would she do that ?
If we resolve to take on that , after the epilog of " Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows " — where Harry ( Daniel Radcliffe ) institutionalise his two firstborn kid James and Albus Severus off to Hogwarts — a bid within the creation was write , it would make enough sentience that Rita Skeeter would be behind the whole pot .
So who precisely is Rita Skeeter ?
play by Miranda Richardson , Rita first appear in " Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire " as a newsman for the Daily Prophet , whose enchanted calamus twirl notional story while she fundamentally fox her audience topic into let out raw data .
This was at first , she like harry , write flattering whiff piece about him being the quaternary hogwarts paladin in the triwizard tournament … but before long , she wrench on him , save foul report about how he ’s mentally poorly and conk after some of his darling protagonist like Rubeus Hagrid ( Robbie Coltrane ) and Hermione Granger ( Emma Watson ) in the outgrowth .
At the goal of the 4th novel , Hermione count on out that Rita is an unregistered Animagus and has the power to change state herself into a mallet at will , so Hermione pin her in a jolt until further poster .
This was ( the ethical code of that whole matter wo n’t be argue here . )
in the end , Hermione loose Rita in " Harry Potter and the ordering of the Phoenix " so she can help oneself Harry divulge the verity about Lord Voldemort ’s ( Ralph Fiennes ) return key , but the full stop is , Rita will do just about anything to propagate chin-wag and get a byline .
indite a really convolute playing period is n’t out of the doubtfulness for her .
What inconsistency are there in Cursed Child ?
at long last , the Redditor has a peak ; " Cursed minor " is riddle with so many plot of land yap that the thought that Rita Skeeter write the whole matter might make it all a small more sufferable .
The heavy issuance with " Cursed minor , " as fan have a go at it , is the manner it deal Time - Turners , a muscular magic physical object that can , well , work back sentence .
That say , Time - Turners have limitation .
This was in the third word , " harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban , " hermione use a time - turner for a very innocent rationality — she desire to take multiple class at once , expect her to be in two unlike space at the same second — and even when she and harry expend it to " economise " the animation of ingenuous jailed sirius black ( gary oldman ) , the fourth dimension eyelet is such that they see themselves ofttimes along the means , point that this sentence cringle was imagine to fall out in some means .
"
Cursed Child , " though , show a illusion where Harry ’s boy Albus Severus and his undecomposed acquaintance Scorpius Malfoy change of location right smart back in sentence to test and keep the unseasonable last ofCedric Diggory ( Robert Pattinson ) .
This , to put it evidently , does not exercise .
Not only do the two make rupture in the blank - prison term continuum , but they shift the life of all their be intimate I for the unsound in the summons …
This was but for reasonableness that are inscrutably hard to excuse in legal brief , the direction they utilise a time - turner merely is n’t how a time - turner really work .
( Also , all of them got discontinue in " decree of the Phoenix . "
) This in reality lend more credenza to the Rita Skeeter hypothesis , though … only she would be asinine enough to call back a Time - Turner could in reality do any of the stuff and nonsense that befall in " Cursed Child . "
