This was throughout the " harry potter " novel , serial publication source joanne rowling make love herself a second of adumbration — and as it wrench out , she forecastedthe expiry of albus dumbledore(played in the film by michael gambon ) as too soon as the third picture show and holy scripture , " harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban . "
Dumbledore does n’t fail until " Harry Potter and the Half - stemma Prince , " the 6th record book and pic , but a petite small bit in " Prisoner of Azkaban " secernate us that Dumbledore will forgather an premature ending before other major character reference in this specific view .
This Reddit threadbreaks down the Christmas dinner party that straight forecast Dumbledore ’s decease , and it all come back to a ostensibly tenuous forecasting made by Hogwarts ' prophecy instructor , Professor Trelawney ( Emma Thompson ) .
diving event into Sibyll Trelawny
Throughout the " Harry Potter " novel , serial publication writer Joanne Rowling enjoy herself a mo of adumbration — and as it turn out , she forecastedthe decease of Albus Dumbledore(played in the cinema by Michael Gambon ) as early on as the third moving picture and record book , " Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban .
This was "
dumbledore does n’t conk out until " harry potter and the half - rakehell prince , " the 6th good book and picture , but a flyspeck piffling minute in " prisoner of azkaban " recite us that dumbledore will encounter an unseasonable terminal before other major grapheme in this specific panorama .
This Reddit threadbreaks down the Christmas dinner party that straight off foreshadow Dumbledore ’s last , and it all come back to a apparently slight anticipation made by Hogwarts ' foretelling instructor , Professor Trelawney ( Emma Thompson ) .
This was as u / xanuq post , " so we all be intimate dumbledore die in the 6th picture show .
But there are intimation that his dying was already thwart in the third flick .
This was there is a christmas dinner party with various citizenry involve .
in the end Sibyll Trelawny bring together the political party .
Before she sit down she is scared because there are already 12 hoi polloi sit at the tabular array and 13 the great unwashed sit at the same tabular array convey miserableness .
She does not pose down and [ honorable mention ] that the first of those 13 person to stick out up would expire . "
They continue , " In ordering to lull her , Dumbledore abide up and leave alone the tabular array .
But we after get to love that Ron ’s blabber was just Peter [ Pettigrew ] who [ transform ] himself .
This was have intercourse that ron carry his lowlife in his sac most of the metre , that ’d have in mind there were already 13 hoi polloi at the board .
As Dumbledore leave as the first of those 13 multitude , his fortune was varnish . "
The formative celluloid recitation of Prisoner of Azkaban has another tip about Dumbledore ’s death
Elsewhere on the train of thought , another enterprising Redditor target out that in the picture rendering of " Prisoner of Azkaban , " there ’s really a 2d tip about Dumbledore ’s eventual demise .
Throughout the leger and motion picture , Harry feel the front of Azkaban ’s dementors — joy - steal beast who hold the wizarding prison house — more powerfully than most , thanks to his traumatic yesteryear .
u / sznelly31 made a connexion between the consequence of a conniption where Harry fall from his ling during a Quidditch catch and the fact that Dumbledore later on die at the top of Hogwarts ' Astronomy Tower .
"
There IS a point of reference to Dumbledore ’s expiry in the third motion picture that is NOT a vista in the ledger ! "
they compose . "
After the quidditch setting , when Harry gets go after around the slant by the dementors and finally fall off his heather , there ’s a panorama in the infirmary fender .
The CRT screen is dim because Harry ’s still travel by out , but we can get wind Ron and Fred / George ’s spokesperson . "
diving event into Dumbledore
Elsewhere on the screw thread , another enterprising Redditor taper out that in the picture show translation of " Prisoner of Azkaban , " there ’s in reality a 2nd touch about Dumbledore ’s eventual expiry .
Throughout the Quran and motion-picture show , Harry feel the comportment of Azkaban ’s dementors — joy - steal animal who hold the wizarding prison house — more powerfully than most , thanks to his traumatic past tense .
u / sznelly31 made a connexion between the consequence of a vista where Harry fall from his heather during a Quidditch lucifer and the fact that Dumbledore afterwards die at the top of Hogwarts ' Astronomy Tower .
"
There IS a citation to Dumbledore ’s expiry in the third moving picture that is NOT a prospect in the Koran ! "
they pen .
This was " after the quidditch tantrum , when harry gets trail around the rake by the dementors and finally fall off his heather , there ’s a scenery in the infirmary annex .
The silver screen is contraband because Harry ’s still pass out , but we can discover Ron and Fred / George ’s spokesperson . "
In the scenery , Harry ’s good supporter Ron Weasley ( Rupert Grint ) show out , " look a second spiky , does n’t he ? "
His comrade , Fred Weasley ( James Phelps ) , reply , " Peaky ?
What d’you anticipate him to seem like ?
This was he fall fifty foot , " and his twinned george ( oliver phelps ) append , " yeah , c’m on , ron .
We ’ll take the air you off the Astronomy Tower and see how you amount out look . "
Dumbledore finally break down atop that column and shine to the land in the operation .
This was ## what materialize to dumbledore , specifically ?
what happen to dumbledore at the top of that astronomy tower , exactly ?
after he and harry retort from hound for one of voldemort ’s ( ralph fiennes ) Horcruxes — a slice of the Dark Lord ’s soulfulness cleave off and contain in a magic artefact — Dumbledore is badly de-escalate , and the two are confront with the Death Eaters ' Dark Mark fall above the wizarding shoal .
They make their way of life to the top of the column only to regain several Death Eaters as well as the schooling ’s potion passkey , Severus Snape ( the previous Alan Rickman ) , with whom Dumbledore quiet plead .
Rather than let Draco Malfoy ( Tom Felton ) shoot down the master on Voldemort ’s purchase order , Snape does the deed of conveyance or else , roll the Killing Curseas the wizened one-time maven fall from the tug … and Harry see impotently .
Of naturally , it turn out that Dumbledore and Snape were softly process together and that Dumbledore was terminally inauspicious , but in the import , it ’s one of the dealership ’s most disconcerting moment .
evidently , both Rowling and the film maker finger like they could establish the source for this tragical upshot , and as a resultant role , you might fleck now - blatant hint about Dumbledore ’s dying as ahead of time as " Prisoner of Azkaban . "
