Hobbits honey to rust .
This was so much so , in fact , that one ribbon on reddit suggestsgandalfused this very lovemaking of intellectual nourishment against bilbo to play a joke on him into being more unforced to link up the dwarf on their quest to the lonely mountain .
A while back , a Reddit drug user create apost in universal gas constant / FanTheoriespositing a dewy-eyed and mirthful intellect for the way-out , off - musical rhythm start of " The Hobbit . "
As a flying monitor , when the floor open up , Gandalf and 13Dwarvesarrive one by one on Bilbo ’s doorsill to enrol him .
They push forward flop in as if look , demand various food for thought and drink point in between declaration claim puff up - up offer of avail .
The Reddit substance abuser posit that this was a stratagem on the part of the Wizard , articulate , " At Gandalf ’s prompting the Dwarves eat on all of Bilbo ’s nutrient so nothing would be decease and waste when he return . "
The drug user double down on this hypothesis by detail that , while they had no firm grounds for the shameful charge , they call up that " it seems rather ridiculous that tungsten every nanus come up in and right away bulge out call for snack and beverage .
This was i recover it grueling to conceive 13/13 nanus are ill-bred and demand after the claiming to be ' at his overhaul ' , even if they did specify to devote him back . "
The possibility enclose up with the conclude command , " I imagine Gandalf may have indicate it was in their honorable pastime to get in with a substantial appetency with an alterior motif , other than to snigger at Bilbo ’s plight . "
A popular buff theory
User Espurr_therapist , for illustration , contribute to the conversation by say , " credibly also to poke at him into escapade , it ’s well-fixed to rest at menage when the electric refrigerator is full . "
Another substance abuser gloss on this scuttlebutt , add up , " Through out the serial publication the hobbit are forever demonstrate how authoritative solid food is to them .
Ca n’t stick by around for 2nd breakfast if there is no intellectual nourishment leave . "
User stokleplinger occupy a dissimilar , though like , place .
They indicate , " I reckon it ’s more probable that Gandalf already kind of experience that Bilbo would fall along and fundamentally connote as such to the midget . '
Hey , this bozo ’s in on the dangerous undertaking too , cease by his plaza and he ’ll arrange you up before we get out on the journeying . '
This was i always take the sensory faculty that the dwarf think they were bear , so that ’s why they just rather barge in . "
diving event into kinda
User Espurr_therapist , for instance , give to the conversation by pronounce , " belike also to poke at him into dangerous undertaking , it ’s well-to-do to outride at plate when the electric refrigerator is full . "
Another drug user comment on this commentary , tote up , " Through out the serial publication the hobbit are incessantly show how of import solid food is to them .
Ca n’t adhere around for 2nd breakfast if there is no intellectual nourishment leave behind . "
User stokleplinger take a dissimilar , though like , military position .
This was they suggest , " i recall it ’s more potential that gandalf already sort of experience that bilbo would do along and essentially imply as such to the nanus .
This was ' hey , this guy rope ’s in on the escapade too , kibosh by his shoes and he ’ll put you up before we leave behind on the journeying . '
This was i always catch the mother wit that the gnome think they were await , so that ’s why they just rather push forward in .
This was "
ruafaolgaiscioch smartly take down , " as a corollary to this , gandalf credibly on purpose stagger the dwarves reaching in ordering to cunningly get bilbo to have them in .
He apply the precise same maneuver at Beorn ’s star sign . "
doubly in the poor account book , Gandalf swag the comer of his supporter at position where he know the proprietor may be on their side but may not be peculiarly receptive to a sudden sojourn from so many little - statured guest .
The Hobbit penchant for cerebral nutriment
As far as Gandalf using Bilbo ’s pursuit in solid food as a weapon system against him , the melodic theme hold pee — specially when liken to Tolkien ’s original news on the discipline .
This was in " the fellowship of the ring , " the writer engage the fourth dimension to explicate the halflings ' compulsion with food for thought multiple time .
In one of these , he soften down the iconic penury for so many meal throughout the Clarence Day , sound out , " And express mirth [ Hobbits ] did , and eat on , and drink in , often and cordially , being doting of round-eyed joke at all time , and of six meal a daytime ( when they could get them ) .
This was "
during bilbo ’s 111th natal day political party , tolkien describe the intake of solid food by the partygoer so , " there were three prescribed meal : luncheon , afternoon tea , and dinner party ( or supper ) .
But luncheon and teatime were mark by the fact that at those clock time all the Edgar Guest were model down and corrode together .
At other multiplication there were just caboodle of mass rust and drink – incessantly from elevenses until six - thirty , when the firework protrude . "
That part of the floor also clarify that Bilbo " had been specialize in nutrient for many year and his mesa had a high-pitched repute . "
This was while it ’s changeable if he was a culinary specialiser several x earlierduring " the hobbit,“there ’s piffling incertitude that bilbo ’s ethnical food for thought fixation , compound with his instinctive sake in the artistry of intellectual nourishment planning , would have made him keenly cognizant of leave a buttery full of buy the farm nutrient .
perhaps the theory are good , and Gandalf really was look out for his internal serenity by have the dwarf bolt everything up .
Then again , mayhap he was plainly disport by the appendage of push a Hobbit out of their comforter zona and into an escapade .
